+ Reply to Thread
Results 1 to 9 of 9
dqw
  1. #1
    Starving
    Member#
    206
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    DC Metro

    Default  CS alternatives, plus exif question  
      
      

    Hi all,

    New to this forum, due to recently acquiring a D40. Now that I have something more than a basic P&S digital camera, I've been thinking more about post-processing of images.

    I have full access to Photoshop CS3 (Mac) at the office thanks to my job, but for obvious reasons, I'd rather deal with the majority of my personal photos on my personal PC at home. Unfortunately, my home PCs are currently limited to a severely outdated version of PS (5 or 6), some free software I've downloaded but have never been 100% pleased with (GIMP), or the junk bundled with various cameras I've owned (never even bothered with this).

    If I purchase Photoshop Elements 6, what are the major features I'll be losing when compared to CS3? I'm primarily interested in those features that are relevant for basic post-processing, like sharpening tools, levels, curves, and highlight/shadow controls. I'm also curious about the lens correction features present in CS2/3. As relatively new features in the full version of PS, I'm assuming they're stripped out of Elements?

    I guess, in short, what I'm asking is if Elements is worth the $80 over something free like Picasa 2, given that I do have access to CS3, albeit on a limited basis for personal use?

    Finally - my work computer is a Mac running OS X Tiger; is there an exif viewer similar to oPanda for Macs (or is this built in and I'm missing it)?


    • Advertising

      advertising
      newschoolofphotography.com
      has no influence on the ads
      that Google displays.



        
       

  2. #2
    Hat Trick
    Member#
    53
    Join Date
    Jul 2007
    Location
    Some national park...

    Default          

    First off, welcome!

    A good portion of the images on my website were processed/dealt with using Photoshop 5.3 (or similar) back before I got CS2. As for what you'd lose by using Elements vs. CS3, I know you wouldn't have the Shadow/Highlight tool, but I use CS2 so I'm not even familiar with everyhting thats in CS3 but I assume its similar.

    Also, I would expect there's some kind of exif viewer that can be used for Macs, but I'm not sure, maybe a mac user will chime in.

    Sorry if that doesn't help much...

    - Scott

  3. #3
    got band-aids? iunno's Avatar
    Member#
    54
    Join Date
    Jul 2007
    Location
    six feet under

    Default          

    welcome to the forum!

    PS7 is still my favorite but i rock cs3 because everyone recommended it.

    i was looking on download.com for MAC exif viewers but didn't really see anything.

  4. #4
    Working
    Member#
    61
    Join Date
    Aug 2007

    Default          

    iPhoto and Aperture give you the exif info which is why there isn't a popular alternative for macs. But for those of us that hate to open such huge apps just to check the photo info there's Exif Viewer:

    http://homepage.mac.com/aozer/EV/

  5. #5
    cold-blooded internet insult machine Markitos's Avatar
    Member#
    74
    Join Date
    Aug 2007
    Location
    Durham, NC

    Default          

    Quote Originally Posted by Stime187 View Post
    As for what you'd lose by using Elements vs. CS3, I know you wouldn't have the Shadow/Highlight tool, but I use CS2 so I'm not even familiar with everyhting thats in CS3 but I assume its similar.
    Actually, Elements DOES have the shadows/highlights tool. Think of Elements as a shortcut for a lot of common photoshop functions. When I don't need to use actions/do a lot of work on a photo, Elements usually gets the job done.

    That said, I use CS3 and/or Capture NX when processing RAWs, doing more thorough PP work.
    “Sharpness is a Bourgeois concept.” -- Henri Cartier-Bresson

  6. #6
    Working
    Member#
    61
    Join Date
    Aug 2007

    Default          

    Another comment about info on Macs ... I was assuming you wanted the complete exif data. If not, if you only need the basics (exposure, aperture, camera, etc) you can just "Get Info" on any photo. Quick key is cmd + i

  7. #7
    Starving
    Member#
    206
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    DC Metro

    Default          

    Heh, I've been 100% PC until about 2 months ago - and even now I only use one at work. Thanks for the link of Exif Viewer, that's exactly what I wanted. Haven't made up my mind about PS Elements yet. I still have PS 6 that I'm using, so maybe I'll hold off.

  8. #8
    Working
    Member#
    61
    Join Date
    Aug 2007

    Default          

    Quote Originally Posted by another View Post
    iPhoto and Aperture give you the exif info which is why there isn't a popular alternative for macs. But for those of us that hate to open such huge apps just to check the photo info there's Exif Viewer:

    http://homepage.mac.com/aozer/EV/
    Quote Originally Posted by another View Post
    Another comment about info on Macs ... I was assuming you wanted the complete exif data. If not, if you only need the basics (exposure, aperture, camera, etc) you can just "Get Info" on any photo. Quick key is cmd + i
    Preview also supports complete exif info now so there's no need for Exif Viewer at all. The 2 quick keys are then:

    basic info: cmd +i when the image is selected in finder (on desktop, etc)

    complete info: double-click image to open in Preview (or press cmd + down). Press cmd +i, select Details tab.

  9. #9
    Working
    Member#
    61
    Join Date
    Aug 2007

    Default          

    Quote Originally Posted by ForceFed4 View Post
    Heh, I've been 100% PC until about 2 months ago - and even now I only use one at work. Thanks for the link of Exif Viewer, that's exactly what I wanted. Haven't made up my mind about PS Elements yet. I still have PS 6 that I'm using, so maybe I'll hold off.
    If you want more Macness, get Pixelmator which blows the doors off Elements. Amazingly beautiful app that does quite a bit for such a low cost.

+ Reply to Thread Go Back to forum

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts