
Originally Posted by
another
I'm going to chime here again about the tele cuz, in general, I fall into the same rarely-use-a-tele category as some of the other folks in here ... but what I was trying to get at is this is likely one of your "trips of a lifetime" and why in the heck would you (or anybody) limit your kit when weight and theft aren't much an issue??? If you've got a walk-around camera bag that fits the lenses you like, bring them!!
1) It doesn't sound like you will be doing any trekking. That means when you are out and about with a camera you will not have your luggage/pack with you ... just a camera bag. (i.e. weight should not be an issue)
2) There is always risk of theft/mugging when you travel (or around home!), however, I would have no fear bringing anything with me to Peru. I've been around most of south america and though Peru can feel more third world than a lot of other countries, it has never seemed dangerous to me. I have never been mugged in that country. I've never been threatened. You will likely be more frightened reading Lonely Planet's recommendations for places to avoid than in any real life situation you find yourself. I mean, you are going to one of the most popular tourist areas in the world ... you will not find yourself in a dark alley surrounded by the Shining Path. (i.e. theft shouldn't be an above average concern)
3) Speaking probabilistically, it is unlikely you will ever be back. Even if you take only a single photo with that lens, it is a photo/memory you would not have otherwise. IMO, you either bring all your photo stuff and try to maximize your photography, or you leave it all at home and maximize your experience. (i.e. don't miss a once-in-a-lifetime shot or don't travel through your viewfinder)
4) In Peru (and most of south america) you have to pay people to take their picture. Or rather, you will be hassled endlessly by the poor if they catch you snapping a shot of them. And you will surely take photos of them. Many dress in traditional clothing and hang around town for just that purpose. If you want free, less posed, and more natural shots of the locals you will want some distance.
5) I have only a handful of tele shots from all my hiking trips in south america (where weight was a big deal), but I would never consider going without one. Especially the 70-200 f/4 which is ideally suited for it and makes many a Nikon hiker jealous.
Obviously you gotta do what you are comfortable doing, but speaking from experience, and knowing I like photography a hell of a lot less than anybody else on here, I would never limit my kit if I were going someplace special.
My $.02, hope it helps. Most importantly, have a kick ass adventure!